Life in Stride Podcast · Episode 360
John Davis - Marathon Excellence for Everyone, Explaining the Best Training and Fueling Methods
Published August 20, 2026 · 92 min · With John Davis
Episode Summary
John Davis, author of Marathon Excellence and a 2:29 marathoner (Woodlands, Grandma's), joins Chris Striegel, Scotty Scearce and Danny Perkins. He talks about his path from a 5:40 freshman mile in Minnesota through D3 running at Carleton. He explains why runners with high school and college backgrounds tend to have an edge in the marathon: years of VO2 max-focused racing give them a high aerobic ceiling to build on. He argues that a Boston qualifier is mainly a problem of endurance, which training can fix, and not of talent.
Davis lays out the physiological roots of marathon fitness: VO2 max, steady state max, running economy and resilience. He then covers fueling. He usually starts runners at 45–50 g of carbs per hour, sees 80–90 g as a healthy target, and remains skeptical of 120 g+ for road marathoners. He also describes his Canova-influenced plans, including the Hurricane plan, which peaks at 120 miles. These plans use long fast runs at 90–95% of marathon pace, 1K on/off sessions, and a general, then supportive, then specific phase structure in which VO2 max work comes early in the build.
The conversation also covers a short taper of about 10 days to two weeks, with Emile Cairess's 215K week before London 2024 as an example. Davis explains why volume drops roughly 15% in the specific phase and how double threshold can fit between big marathon workouts. Other topics include pace-based coaching, mileage as a load metric, why cross-training doesn't replace running volume, Claudio Berardelli lowering volume for older athletes, and post-race recovery and planning between blocks.
Key Takeaways
- Davis's long fast runs are 15–22 miles at 90–95% of marathon pace, for example about 6:18/mile for a 2:37 marathoner.
- Fueling lets you express fitness but doesn't build it; Davis starts athletes at 45–50 g/hour, aims for 60–90 g, and weighs gut issues against marginal gains.
- In marathon periodization, VO2 max and CV work is general training placed early, while work at 95–105% of marathon pace is most specific and comes closest to the race.
- Davis favors a taper of about 10 days to two weeks, with a final 8–10 x 1K on/off workout about 10 days out and no new high-intensity sessions.
- Volume drops about 15% in the marathon-specific phase so athletes can recover from bigger workouts, and easy days serve the quality of those sessions.
- Double threshold isn't required for marathoners, but a scaled-down session can add low-stress quality between two big weekend workouts.
- After a marathon, Davis has athletes do light running within 3–5 days, then short, fast work like hill repeats and 5K-pace efforts before rebuilding volume.
Questions Answered in This Episode
How many grams of carbs per hour should I take in a marathon?
John Davis usually starts runners at 45 to 50 grams per hour and tries to push it up, saying 80 to 90 is a healthy place to be for runners with an iron stomach. He is skeptical of 100 to 120+ grams per hour for road marathoners, noting a bathroom stop costs more than any marginal benefit.
What is steady state max in marathon training?
John Davis explains steady state max is the highest intensity where heart rate, oxygen consumption and blood lactate stay stable; it's what people mean by threshold, CV or maximal lactate steady state. He suggests thinking of it as a percentage of VO2 max, which combined with running economy determines threshold pace.
How long should a marathon taper be?
John Davis is taper skeptical and thinks no more than two weeks, maybe 10 days, of somewhat lighter training is needed. He likes a last big 1K on/off workout about 10 days out, something light six days out, and a low-volume threshold session like 8 x 3 minutes the Wednesday before the race.
What is a Canova-style 1K on/off marathon workout?
John Davis describes fast 1K, 2K or 3K reps at marathon pace or about 5% faster alternated with a float at 85 to 90% of marathon pace. Chris Striegel did 8 x 1K on/off at 105% (3:15/K) and 90% (3:50/K) within a 22-mile run.
Is double threshold necessary for marathon training?
John Davis says it is not required, since most top marathoners don't do it, but it can be useful. He uses it either as general aerobic training or as a low-stress midweek session between big marathon-specific workouts, warning that double threshold alone doesn't prepare you for the full marathon.
What should I do after running a marathon?
John Davis takes two weeks off from training but often gets runners doing light easy running three to five days after if nothing hurts. He then starts with short, fast, low-volume work like 10 x 1 minute, hill repeats or 5K-pace running before rebuilding the general phase.
Want a coach in your corner?
1-on-1 online run coaching: a personalized training plan, weekly check-ins with your coach, and a team to train with.
Apply for CoachingA coach will call or text you within 24 hours
Full Transcript
Lightly edited for readability: filler words and false starts removed.
NA beers and John's Rao's spaghetti pre-marathon meal
Chris Striegel
You got a Modelo NA?
Scotty Scearce
Yes, and it's actually fire. It's Limón y Sal. It's
Danny Perkins
Dude, those are good. I had one of those for the first time at my parents' house the other weekend. Those are super good.
Scotty Scearce
Very good.
Chris Striegel
But I got some of those.
Scotty Scearce
The NA world is expanding rapidly. Every time I go to the store there's a new NA.
Chris Striegel
John, are you an NA beer drinker or no?
John Davis
I have had the OG Athletic Brewing, and it's great. And I guess that probably kicked off the boom, at least among athletes, I think.
Chris Striegel
I remember, I don't know if you guys remember or know, but there's this guy named Bobby Curtis. He was a good pro marathoner back in the day. He went to my high school, and he was the first person I ever heard say that he drinks NA beers for the carbs. And I was like, that's such a crazy thought process, but it's not that crazy, I guess. There's no harm with it, right? But that was in 2010 or something. I heard that and I was like, that's crazy.
He was doing it. So good choice, Scotty. I got some of those Chelato ones in my fridge right now. Very good. But go ahead, Danny.
Danny Perkins
John, what's your go-to carb-rich meal or beverage?
John Davis
I'm a pasta guy, right? Spaghetti dinner. That's my jam. That's my pre-marathon. I have this very calibrated, okay, this kind of sauce and these noodles, and I have that before the really big workouts too. So I'm very meticulous and precise with how I want. And I don't do that for all of my eating, because I think that's not good. But for that twenty-four hours or so before either a marathon or a really big workout, I've got this brand of pasta noodles, this brand of sauce.
Scotty Scearce
How dialed in are we talking here, John? How dialed in? Are we measuring stuff?
Danny Perkins
What's the brand? Name names.
John Davis
Okay. So it's Rao's Homemade. There's a variety of the sauce without onions and garlic, because those are rich in something called FODMAPs, which can cause gastrointestinal issues in some people. I don't know if I'm one of those or not, but after I wrote that part of the book, I was like, okay, I better make sure I'm not. And then there's, I don't remember the exact brand of noodle, but traditional Italian-style spaghetti noodles are pretty thick. They're white wheat, not whole grain, again to watch the fiber content. And it's those two. Boil the water, cook the noodles, heat up the sauce. And I like it because I can make it even if I'm traveling, where usually you can get that sauce or something like it.
I think the last time I traveled for a race, I actually brought the noodles with me in my carry-on. Just like, am I gonna be able to get to a grocery store? I don't know.
Chris Striegel
Yeah, I know a lot of people that do that, and I've been wondering if I need to start doing that. I just don't know. So, funny story: I was at Division II Nationals in college for cross country, and they ran out of chicken at the buffet. There was a pre-race thing with all the teams there. And my college coach was so worried that they were gonna undercook the chicken and rush it out that he was like, "We're storming out, we're leaving, we're going to Olive Garden, I'm not risking this." And I was like, I don't think they're gonna undercook the chicken, but I'm fine on
John Davis
Well, that's what freaks me out, is the food poisoning the night before the race from the restaurant. That is always on my mind.
John's hamstring tendinopathy and tendon rehab
Chris Striegel
Are you gearing up for a fall race of any kind?
John Davis
No, I've been injured for a while, so I haven't been training much. Been more focused on the coaching and the writing and the science stuff.
Chris Striegel
What's the injury?
John Davis
I had high hamstring tendinopathy for quite a while. And then actually that's been feeling better, but I have some kind of secondary foot stuff going on. So hopefully we'll get back into it in the fall and see if I can take a few more cracks at the marathon. But I did Grandma's last year, so not this past, not recently, but the year before that. That was my last big race.
Chris Striegel
Man, that hamstring tendinopathy is really hard to get rid of for a lot of people. People have it for years.
John Davis
Yeah, it just sticks around for so long. Just been doing the strength stuff. I'm very well accustomed with all the latest research on tendon rehab now, though. So that's kind of a plus.
Chris Striegel
Yeah, I've been going down the... well, I have Achilles issues, and you gotta do heavy stuff a lot, for sure, and constantly be progressively loading it. So it's a long game for sure with tendon stuff, unfortunately. So it is what it is. Danny, yours is feeling better though, isn't it?
Danny Perkins
Feeling a lot better. I got a strength training program going on right now, and I'm lifting once, twice max a week, and it's done wonders for my running.
John Davis
Good to hear it.
From 5:40 freshman miler to D3 at Carleton: why college runners excel at the marathon
Chris Striegel
That'll do it. John, when did you start running? Were you a middle school, high school runner, college runner, or did you start after?
John Davis
My parents signed me up for middle school cross country, probably to keep me out of trouble. And then I ran in high school, cross country and track. And I was pretty slow. I think my freshman year I was 5:40 in the mile. And then I got into training in the winter and in the summer, because in Minnesota we don't have indoor track. So it's just spring track and fall cross country. So I started running a lot in the summer and the winter and then just kept getting better.
And then I ran D3 in college down at Carleton, and so I kind of came up through the traditional path: high school cross and track, college cross country and track. And so I kind of still speak that lingo. And so it's interesting to talk to people now who got into running during COVID, or they played soccer or something else, or hockey, and then they come directly into marathons, right? Where for me it was, okay, a mile, two mile, 5k, 10k. Half marathon. Marathon. All roughly in that order chronologically.
Chris Striegel
It's funny. I had the same: started in middle school, ran through college. Most people I ran with through those time periods got burnt out and do not run anymore, or hobby jog. Most of the people I train with, like these two guys, started post-collegiately, right? And that's my main crew I train with now, and they're very passionate about it. So that's the group you wanna be around. But it is funny, especially running high school and college, people do get burnt out more often than not.
And I guess, I don't know, I just do structured training for a long time. I guess whereas on you mentally and natural will take a break after.
John Davis
Yeah. And it's not always easy to predict who will stick with it. There were people who were teammates of mine in college where they were so into running. They were like, let's run every day. They were watching live streams from European track meets. And then after college, they just never ran a step again, or ran for a little bit and then quit. And then there were a few other guys. There was one friend of mine who I ended up later coaching. He was a 400, 800 guy in college. Ran 20 miles a week. He would do a big four-mile long run on Saturdays. And then after college, he got into road racing, started running a hundred miles a week, and got really good.
And so it's just really bizarre. It's always surprising who ends up sticking with it and who is just like, nah, I'm done. I'm toast.
Danny Perkins
There's a noticeable difference too of those that ran at any collegiate level. It could be the lowest collegiate level. And I would probably venture to say Scotty and I, had we trained in high school, probably could have gotten on the lowest collegiate level of runner. So from an athletic standpoint of just ability, athletic ability is this cover-all term that is not defined very well, but I would say that we're pretty on par with a lot of these people who we see on start lines today. Yet they had these four years of structured training in college, sometimes a grad school year too, that somehow puts them so far ahead developmentally than the latecomer to the sport who just starts off in the marathon. Why do you think it is that those athletes are so much faster at the marathon than latecomers like me and Scotty?
John Davis
I think a big part of it is that that traditional pipeline of coming up through high school and college training is basically a super intensive four- or eight-year block of VO2 max-focused work. 3,000 meters, 5,000 meters and the training for it, or 8k cross country, that is just slamming your aerobic system up to its limit every week or every other week for six months out of the year, regardless of how good or bad your training is. Not that it doesn't matter what the rest of your training is, but even if you're on some high school team where they just went running and played Frisbee, you're still running eighteen minutes really hard over hills every single weekend for eight weeks. And that just cranks your aerobic power really high.
You've gained some large percentage of, say you have some theoretical what your VO2 max could be, sort of genetic potential. You get to climb up a lot of that, and then that gives you a big, easy platform to build on. So you don't have to solve the problem of, I need to increase my VO2 max, my aerobic power for shorter events, and also become able to run the full marathon.
You just need to be able to take the aerobic fitness you have and then be able to go some large fraction of it for a really long time. And so you have a smaller set of problems you're dealing with.
Chris Striegel
Makes sense.
Scotty Scearce
Chris, are you getting PTSD?
Danny Perkins
Their ceiling's really high.
Chris Striegel
I really enjoyed running all the years I ran in school. But I had some friends doing all-out 200s at the track in middle school and stuff, and those were the friends that ended up being the good 800-meter, miler, good top-end speed, because they worked on it with whatever coach or training program they were in in middle school here in Louisville. They pretty much did all-out 200s once a week, and in turn they had really good top-end speed for their whole career. So I wish I was on that wave in middle school, but I was doing four-mile tempos and stuff more regularly. And of course I'm more of an aerobic guy, so I guess that makes sense. So I don't know how much that early on plays into your development, but I would be interested to know.
John Davis
Yeah, it's funny too. Sometimes people change as they go through adolescence, in their athletic configuration. When I was coaching high school, we had many cases where someone would seem like a long distance runner when they were in middle school, and then suddenly they turn 17 and they just have this unreal foot speed, almost out of nowhere. And so I have no idea exactly what you do or how that affects what the trajectory is, but it's super interesting when you see it.
Chris Striegel
All right, Danny.
Danny Perkins
I was gonna change the trajectory and talk about your concepts behind marathon training. Chris, did you wanna add on something to that piece before I turn the ship?
Does talent matter for qualifying for Boston?
Chris Striegel
Yeah, I was gonna ask about this later, but it fits in right now. How much do you think talent plays into running? Because we coach a good amount of runners ourselves, and people are like, "I don't know if I can qualify for Boston ever, I'm too far away." And I like to tell people, and I think this is true, that anyone can qualify for a race like Boston. I think that's attainable if you just commit to growing your aerobic base, and it doesn't really matter how gifted your top-end speed is.
But I'm curious, from your opinion, obviously at the pro level, your genetics and stuff really do matter. But for someone maybe trying to qualify for a race like Boston, do talent and genetics matter as much as just being able to commit to the grind of marathon training?
John Davis
Yeah, I'll take all the talent I can get, right? I always jokingly tell people, choose your parents carefully. But I think it can be simultaneously true that talent helps a lot, and if we're talking about really high levels of performance, it is important. But also, I don't see very many people where I can say, yeah, they really got close to what I think their base potential is. And I do quite often see people who reach levels of fitness that you would never, ever have believed they'd be able to reach.
There's this great, I think it's maybe Zach Panning, some American pro. On his Instagram he's got a picture of him running a cross country race in middle school. And he's this big, chubby kid running eight-minute miles, and one day that's gonna be a guy running five-minute miles for the whole marathon.
And similarly, even at a much more... we're talking about qualifying for Boston. I think in an absolute sense, it's not that fast for most people. And I don't even mean compared to people who ran in college or whatever. I just mean you can probably run 400 meters, 800 meters, a mile at that speed. It's not that hard. It's a bit like the four-minute mile is a different category, right? Where many people physically cannot run that fast for more than five seconds, right? So that's a different situation than, you want to qualify for Boston, 6:45 mile pace. The problem is a problem of endurance. And it's much easier to build endurance than it is to build speed.
So almost never do I look at someone and say, yeah, this person's real problem is a lack of talent. Generally there's quite a lot you can do in training. And there are heights you can reach that you would not believe you could reach if you had a naive, talent-focused vision of what's possible.
Danny Perkins
Hundred percent agree.
Chris Striegel
Nice. Love that.
Scotty Scearce
I feel like that's all of us, hearing that story. You're like, there's no way that I can run that fast one day. That was me five years ago. I would have never fathomed running a marathon at 5:53 pace, my PR. I was like, that's impossible. I couldn't run a mile that fast. And then five years later, you put in the work in that five-year span and you can do it. I like that story. It's good.
Chris Striegel
Yeah, if anyone's listening and is doubting if they can qualify for Boston, there it is. Right there. You can do it. Just train hard. But all right, Danny. Okay, it's got
Scotty Scearce
But the road is definitely different person to person. My story's not Danny's story, is not Chris's story. It's extremely different per runner. Sometimes it takes somebody six months, sometimes it takes them fifteen years.
John Davis
I mentioned my freshman mile PR was 5:40. That ended up being my marathon pace now, but that took, actually, fifteen years to get there, something like that.
John's 2:29 PRs at Woodlands and a hot Grandma's Marathon
Chris Striegel
Nice. Which race is your PB at?
John Davis
Technically my PB is at the Woodlands Marathon down in Texas. So I ran low 2:29 there, and then also ran 2:29, but a little bit slower than my PB, at Grandma's. I think Grandma's was a better race, though. It was quite hot that year. And so I was
Chris Striegel
It's very hot.
Scotty Scearce
It's always hot at Grandma's.
John Davis
Yeah, they just announced they're moving Twin Cities Marathon further into the fall. And I wish they would take Grandma's Marathon and move it earlier in the spring. It's June twenty-something.
That's why I signed up: I was coming off the winter in much better shape than I thought, and I was like, I gotta get in a race here, and was able to get into Grandma's. But June twenty-something is late for America.
Chris Striegel
Really? Yeah, it's really
Danny Perkins
It's late, and the crazy thing is you can get a forty-degree day there, but you can also get a sixty-five-degree day. Seventy.
Scotty Scearce
You can get an eighty-degree day there.
John Davis
Yes. It's a coin flip whether you're gonna get forty and a nice tailwind the whole way, or what we got, which was seventy-five, sunny, humid, and not much in the way of wind helping you out either.
Steady state max, VO2 max, running economy and resilience
Danny Perkins
So the first chapter of your book is the core principles of marathon training. And the first principle is "marathon fitness has physiological roots." And those are listed as VO2 max, SS max, running economy, and resilience. The one that I haven't really comprehended or thought of before is the SS max. Do you want to talk about those and how they play together for the physiological part?
John Davis
Yeah, so steady state max, as I say it in the full expanded form. That's what a lot of people are talking about when they say threshold or CV or some of these indicators of aerobic fitness. Maximal lactate steady state, you'll hear people say that sometimes. Those are all different experimental tools to try to get at this underlying physiological concept of steady state max. And even though you may not have been able to wrap your head around it, when I explain it, I'm sure you'll be thinking, I know what this means, effort-wise.
It is the highest intensity where you can maintain a metabolic steady state. So your heart rate is stable, your oxygen consumption is stable, your blood lactate is stable, and you're not getting progressively more fatigued very quickly. So right at that speed or a little bit below it, everything's stable. And then above that speed, things are drifting towards whatever their terminal value is. So your VO2 is rising towards VO2 max, your heart rate's rising towards your heart rate max, your blood lactate is rising up towards whatever your lactate capacity is. And all those things trend together. So roughly speaking, either they're all stable over time, or they're all drifting up towards some terminal value.
And the way to think about steady state max, if you're trying to disaggregate marathon performance into separate components, we often say threshold pace or CV pace or whatever. But the way to think about it is as a percentage of your VO2 max, because that allows you to say, okay, my VO2 max is this, and this percentage of it I can maintain at a metabolic steady state. And then that amount of aerobic power output, you essentially get to multiply it by your running economy, and that gives you how fast you're running at that speed.
So your so-called threshold pace is a combination of those things: both the intensity you can maintain at a steady state, and then the conversion rate of that intensity to forward motion, which is what running economy is. So one of the things that's interesting physiologically about modern elite marathoners: they don't have a VO2 max that's shockingly higher than back in the day when 2:10 was an elite marathon time. And the running economy is somewhat better, but it's not shockingly better.
What's better is they can run a higher percentage of their VO2 max and maintain a steady state. And then, pertinent to that resilience thing, they can also maintain a very high percentage of that steady state for a really long time without their body breaking down and deteriorating.
Danny Perkins
And is resilience a factor of strength, or is it how well you can... What is resilience? Talk about that more.
John Davis
It's your ability to resist deterioration in basically the other aspects of fitness. So some of it is how well your muscles resist physical damage. We were talking about Grandma's Marathon. Grandma's starts with several miles of net downhill running. If you haven't done any hill training, or you haven't done the kind of training to resist that sort of muscle damage, you are gonna be in a lot of trouble later in the race because your muscles will become physically damaged.
But that's not the only thing. There's also an ability to resist the buildup of some of the metabolic byproducts that happen when you're running at a high-end aerobic steady state. I'm not talking about lactic acid or the stuff that gets you fatigued in a 5k or a mile race. There are other biochemical components that just gradually accumulate when you're churning through aerobic energy at a really high level for a really long time. And again, people differ, and depending on their training differ, in terms of how affected they are by that. So literally the ability of the muscles to contract, the electrical signal getting to the muscle and making it contract, gets modulated by some of these byproducts. So it's also resistance to that kind of fatigue.
And then there's the carbohydrate aspect, of course, which is: are you running out of fuel? Do you have fuel coming in? Are you having to shift to less efficient fuel sources such as fat? That's another piece of physiological resilience as well.
Carbs per hour: minimum fueling, 120g/hr skepticism and low-fuel elites
Chris Striegel
Speaking of carbohydrates, what is the bare minimum grams per hour someone should be taking? I like to tell people the 75 to 100 range is pretty... If someone's taking 50 grams per hour, I'm usually like, we need to bump it up a little bit. But what would you say is the minimum someone should be taking to minimize the risk of bonking in a marathon?
John Davis
I try to get people to some workable level first and then see if we can bring it up. So usually I will start at 45 or 50, and just make sure, if someone's like, "I don't really feel at all," or they haven't done a marathon before. This is kind of the downside of people who came up through college, right? At least for me, we never took sports drinks or gels on long runs. Like, what are you talking about?
Chris Striegel
Never, never.
John Davis
If we'd had beers the night before, that was the only carb. You just roll out of bed, put your shoes on and go do the long run. And that's a disadvantage, right?
So I try to get people to some workable level and then see if we can push it up. And I know, my guy, social media, people talking 100, 120 grams an hour. My personal experience has been that for some decent fraction of people, I don't know, half of runners, it's a real challenge even to get to 60 or 70. And if we can get there, then I'm pretty happy. And there starts to become a trade-off where it's like, okay, well, I can try fueling more aggressively, but if I lose five minutes 'cause I have to hit the porta potties halfway through, that's obviously way worse than any marginal benefit of 100 over 80 grams an hour.
But if there are some people where they're like, "Yep, got an iron stomach, can take as many gels as I want, no problem," then yeah, sure. I think 80, 90 is a pretty good, pretty healthy place to be. I'm still somewhat skeptical of the real benefits of these extreme fueling rates for...
Chris Striegel
Extreme highs, yeah.
John Davis
...specifically for road marathoners. Different situation for ultramarathon, different situation for elite cycling, even different situation for truly elite marathoning, where you have personal bottles every 5k. There's the other practical aspect: if you're just a random person running Boston, you are carrying that fuel with you. When you're like, "Okay, I'm gonna take 10 gels in this race," okay, well, where are you gonna put them, right?
I'm open to changing my mind if there's more research on the very, very high fueling rates, but I just haven't seen what would be sufficient to convince me yet that I should try to get everybody to 120 or something like that.
Scotty Scearce
What about extreme lows? 'Cause I know a couple buddies who have been in the 2:20s or 2:30 marathons and taking 20 grams an hour on average, and they just don't bonk. Some specimen humans, it feels like.
John Davis
There's this really cool study from maybe 2010 where they took television broadcast footage of elite marathons, they bought the same water bottles that they used, and with a stopwatch they timed on the broadcast how long they were squeezing the bottle. And they calculated, okay, how much fluids were they taking, and from a reasonable estimate of sports drink content, this is back before gels were common, how much fuel are they taking in. And it was 15 grams an hour. It's nothing. And the hydration too was very low.
Now it's an open question: are they just getting away with it, or is that actually optimal for them? My guess is that they're probably getting away with that in a way that really optimal fueling might have taken a minute, two minutes off of their time.
There's also one of the things about a lot of really good marathoners: they have a physical body build that is conducive to not running out of fuel, and I think you can ameliorate that with fueling. The issue is basically, for a given runner of a given running economy, their total caloric cost of running, and therefore the amount of carbs they need, is a function of their total body mass. But the carbs you have available in your muscles are a function of how much lower body muscle mass you have, because it's stored locally in the muscle. So if you're very small but have really long or really muscular legs, and your upper body's really small, you have this strategic advantage in a low fueling situation where you can get away with not fueling very aggressively. So I think some of it is that.
And then also there are people where their stomach is just the limiting factor. And if that's what we gotta do, that's what we gotta do. I think in the intro to the book, I say at the end of the day, you gotta let go of ideology and be pragmatic here. And if the pragmatic situation is, if I try to fuel even at 40 grams an hour, I'm running for the bathroom after 30 minutes, okay, well, we gotta do what we gotta do here and figure out a fix that's gonna get you through the race.
Danny Perkins
If you had to steelman, make the best case for high-carb fueling, what would the argument be for high-carb fueling for a marathon?
John Davis
The basic steelman case is: look, your energetic requirements are very high. You're running at a high metabolic rate. More of your energy is coming from carbohydrates the faster you go. And we know carbohydrates are a more oxygen-efficient fuel than burning fat. This might sound a little confusing, because people have probably heard in health class or nutrition or whatever that fat is more energy dense than carb.
What I'm saying is, for a given amount of oxygen, let's say your VO2 max is 50. That means you have 50 milliliters of oxygen per minute ready per kilogram of body mass. It is more efficient by about 7% to take those 50 milliliters of oxygen and use them to burn carbs than it is to take that same amount of oxygen and use it to burn fat. And because you're limited by the amount of oxygen you have, this is why VO2 max matters, you should be hitting the most efficient fuel that you have as much as you can. And that means burning as many carbohydrates as you possibly can. So that's the strongest case for it.
And I think another thing people would mention is you can do so-called gut training. You can become more able to handle very high rates of carbohydrates. So that's the case. And I think it's a really strong case. And I'm 80% on board, at least, with that.
Chris Striegel
We had, I'm blanking on his name, Ryan Ford, Joe Klecker's teammate on Athletics Club, before and after Boston. They're kind of notorious: in interviews, they said they were going for 130, 140 grams an hour, and everyone was like, "That's crazy." And we asked him about that, and he said essentially they front-load that, but then in the back half they can't really get it down because they've got so much in their gut. So it's really a front-load, and then the last 10k they're really not taking much or anything at all, maybe just water.
So I think when people say they do that much in a marathon, usually they can't make it last the entire way. 'Cause I think they train with that much too, but you don't see many people doing it the whole way.
John Davis
And then maybe the other thing I would say is, if you're a 3:15 marathoner and you ran that pretty evenly and you're trying to hit 2:55 to run Boston, better fueling is not the whole ticket. You have a fitness situation, right? Maybe the most concise way to put it is: fueling allows you to express your fitness at the highest level possible, but it doesn't make you a more fit runner. You have to actually do the training. It's not some magical gel sports drink combination that raises where your fitness is.
Scotty Scearce
You're not one fueling plan away from a BQ, per se. You gotta put it...
John Davis
And I worry sometimes, because fueling is something that you can talk all day about and strategize about and get sponsored by fueling companies and blah blah blah. There's nobody that's like, "I'm gonna sponsor runners to do longer long runs," right? So I worry that people sometimes fixate on that kind of thing, or they fixate on some really technical strength routine or some supplement thing, when it's like, no, we gotta take a step back and look at the training that's setting your fitness level. That's the thing that's really... For you, right? For example, running 5:53s for the marathon, it wasn't just, "I switched to a different sports drink," right? 95% of that was the training you did.
Long fast runs and Canova-style 1K on/off workouts in the Hurricane plan
Danny Perkins
So you have these marathon training plans in your book, and they're awesome because their names are the Tornado and the Hurricane and...
Scotty Scearce
Dude, I was laughing at the names. I love the names.
Danny Perkins
...and the Hurricane is the most elite one, and I'll admit I'm a little hurricane curious. Hurricaneous. So it's 120 miles a week for the top end of mileage for this plan. And as we talk about what's the actual 95%, I would probably even call it 99%, is the training. What is different about your training plans that you don't think is traditional to marathon training?
John Davis
I think for most people, when they look at the plans, the two or maybe three things that they will see that are like, "I've never done anything like that before," are gonna be, number one, the long fast run. So this is runs of 15 to 20, 22 miles at 90 or 95% of marathon pace. So pretty fast. Let's say you're a 3:05 marathoner, that's seven-minute mile pace. 95% of that is about 7:20. Or for a 2:37 marathoner, that's six-minute miles; that means a whole long run at 6:18 per mile. So moving quite fast. That's substantially faster than most people would do for their long runs. So that's one piece.
Another piece that most people do not do is these Canova-style fast 1k or 2k or 3k, either at marathon pace or about 5% faster, depending on the workout, and then a floating kilometer, still 85 to 90% of marathon pace. So still moving pretty fast. And doing that on, off, on, off, on, off. Most people don't do those kinds of workouts. You did? Okay. What was the...
Chris Striegel
I just did that this past weekend.
Scotty Scearce
Yeah, I was gonna say, Chris, sound familiar?
John Davis
Can I ask what the workout was?
Chris Striegel
It was 22 miles total, but in the middle of it, it was eight miles warm-up, eight times 1k on/off. The ons were 105% of marathon pace, which was 3:15s, and then the offs were 3:50, so 90% of marathon pace. It was hot, it was tough. It was hot, but got it done.
But yeah, I was gonna say, on your website there's a review from Canova, and you were just talking about those long runs too, which I know he's a big fan of. So I was like, Canova must totally agree with your mindset on the marathon, 'cause it sounds like he would, which is awesome.
John Davis
Well, you know how those workouts go then. Having to control the pace of the recovery is such a weird, unusual thing for people who came up through kind of the American-style training. Speaking of Canova, the whole Italian system is thinking about every piece of training in terms of some percentage and some outcome you're trying to get out of it. So it's very natural for them and their mindset, but for us it's like, wait, what? Run fast on the recovery? How am I supposed to recover?
Chris Striegel
I think for most people, you're totally right, for the long runs, just getting out the door, maybe doing a mile easy, then locking in for an hour 45, two hours at near marathon pace is something that scares a lot of people. But we're training to run 26.2 at a pretty hard pace. We can't go out and do that on a long run, but we can have somewhat of a simulation where you're practicing your fueling, you're running a consistent effort for a very long time. And that really helps the mental game too, I think, to just get used to running hard for a really long time.
So that's a scary thing for a lot of people, to go out there and do a long run like that. But I think it's the most important part of a marathon build. So got to do it.
John Davis
And even just from a training theory perspective, to the extent that you haven't done that kind of workout before, that is what you need to do, in the sense that you need to do something new. If you've run 2:45 and you want to run 2:40, well, you can't just do the same training you did to run 2:45. You need something new in training. And quite often that new thing is long and fast, or longer and faster than you've gone before.
General, supportive and specific phases of a marathon build
Chris Striegel
Which is scary, but you're right. You gotta do it if you wanna improve.
I'd love to hear you break down the phases of the marathon build: general, marathon supportive, marathon specific. I think maybe this is a unique setup compared to the more standard American way of training. And I think, from my understanding, it's fairly similar to Canova's thought process. Correct me if I'm wrong, but could you explain that breakdown to people? I think it'd be super interesting to hear.
John Davis
The way I think about the phases of training is very informed by Canova and the broader Italian school. I think the American way of thinking about it is: base training is slower than race pace, then you do race-specific training, which is at race pace, and then you do peaking, which is lower volume and even higher intensity. The Italian way of thinking about it is that you have the specific training. That's the training at or around, plus or minus 5%, the speed of the race. That's the most important thing, and that's the thing you do closest to the race.
We were talking about the long fast run. Let's say somebody's able to go out and do 20 miles at 6:18 pace. Probably that person's ready to run six-minute pace for the whole marathon, if they can also do some work at six-minute pace and maybe some work at 5:42: 95, 100, 105%. The question is, okay, how do you become able to do that 20 miles at 95% of marathon pace? Well, you gotta support that ability using speeds that are a little bit faster and a little bit slower than that 95 to 105% range. So you get 90 and 110% there. That's marathon supportive training. It's building the pieces you need to do the specific training.
And then you can play that same game one more level below and say, okay, how do I build the ability to do those long and fast sessions that are specific to the race? Well, I gotta build each of the components of fitness individually across the full spectrum of speeds. So I need to do some long running, but I'm gonna do it easy. And I'm gonna do some fast running, but I'm gonna do it in shorter repeats. And I'm gonna do little baby-sized predecessors of long continuous runs. So I'm not gonna do 16 miles at marathon pace; I'm gonna do five or six or seven. You scale everything down and broaden out the base across speeds, as opposed to "slow, easy running is my base."
If you think about this for the 5k, it maps much more naturally onto how someone doing Daniels training or classic American-style training would think about it, because for the 5k so much of the supportive work is slower than 5k pace, and it maps onto threshold or CV or whatever. But what's weird about the marathon is that it is not that fast of a race. And so you have this whole window of speeds faster than marathon pace, and the Italian school, Canova and friends, say, no, you also need to build that faster than marathon pace. You need to be running 10k pace and 8k pace and 5k pace, maybe even 3k pace. But that's general, because it's 5, 10, 15% faster than marathon pace. It's not specific to the race itself.
So you have this funnel where you narrow down the speeds that you're emphasizing as you get closer to the race. And that's the idea: general phase, very broad; supportive phase, more narrow; specific phase, most narrow and most specific to the demands of the race.
Chris Striegel
So the critical velocity, VO2 stuff would come maybe as you're sharpening up for the race, rather than during the block or earlier in the block, right? Is that what you're saying?
John Davis
So for the marathon, what we would call CV or VO2 max pace is general, because it's much... Yes, it's at the beginning.
Chris Striegel
So it's at the beginning.
John Davis
Like we said with the high school and college training, a high VO2 max is a general ability that's helpful for the marathon, but it's not specific. What's specific is running a high percentage of VO2 max for a very long time. And so how do you do that? Well, first we gotta get the VO2 max up. That's what the CV and VO2 max work is helping to do. Then we gotta be able to run at a strong aerobic pace for a long time. Then we gotta be able to run at marathon pace, or speeds very close to it, for marathon-specific distances.
So it inverts the usual way of thinking about it. For the 5k, the VO2 max and CV stuff is more specific, so it goes closer to the race. Whereas for the marathon, it's less specific because it's too fast and too short, so it goes further away from the race, temporally in training, I mean.
John's 10-day taper and why he's taper skeptical
Chris Striegel
That's interesting. That's definitely a different mindset, because I think people always think, "I need to sharpen up before a race," right? And do that speedier stuff. So that is a different mindset than I would say most Americans have with training.
I was gonna ask too, how in your book do you say to handle the taper? How long is the taper, and what kind of intensity are you doing in the last two weeks, ten days before the race?
John Davis
I am very broadly, not even just for the marathon, but very broadly across the board, somewhat taper skeptical. I don't really believe in this big four-week ramp down in volume. One intuitive way to think about it for the marathon-specific phase is we're almost already doing little miniature tapers for each of the big workouts. So when I was talking about 20 miles at 95% of marathon pace, you don't just do that workout and then run 10 miles the next day and then do a hard workout on Monday. You take several very easy days after that to build back up. And so the whole marathon-specific phase is this pattern of big stress, big recovery, a lighter midweek workout to get ready to go again, a couple more easy days and then another big workout on the weekend. And to the extent that people are doing workouts that are so hard that they're still wrecked two weeks later, I think that's too hard of a workout to do.
So I don't think you need more than two weeks, maybe even 10 days of somewhat lighter training to just get to the starting line feeling good. I also try to talk people down from the magical taper idea where I'm like, look, we're not trying to get some mystical fitness jump. I just want you to get to the starting line feeling good and ready to run the same way you would for just a solid long, fast run or marathon-paced workout.
I just need you to be there. I don't need a miracle. I don't need heroics. I don't need some taper magic. So anyways, okay, that's the philosophy of it. What does it actually look like? What I like as the last major workout is actually basically the workout you did this morning, Chris, just with a shorter warm-up and cooldown. I like eight, nine, maybe ten by 1K, 1K, touching on 3 to 5% faster than marathon pace and then floating more like 90%-ish. Although for that last workout, I'm actually more interested in what the float pace is and less interested in how fast the fast Ks go. Because in the final phases of marathon training, and we're getting a little into technical weeds here, often what happens is you find that those fast Ks can't quite be as fast relative to where your marathon fitness is. Maybe you can only do 103%, but you feel really good on the float. That's the most specific type of marathon-specific minutes.
But anyways, okay, so you do that, say, 10 days before the race, maybe two weeks before the race if you want a more traditional taper. I like 10 or so days before, three easy days, and then something light-ish six days out from the race or so. For more advanced runners, I like something at 10K-ish pace, a controlled CV-style workout. But for lower volume runners, often that'll just be 12 miles with a progressive finish, or some pretty chill workout. And then the Wednesday before the race, just some low-volume threshold thing, eight by three minutes or whatever. Nothing super fast, nothing super high volume, nothing crazy. Just something where you'll come off of it feeling pretty good. Two or three days later, you'll be ready to really run a good race. So that's it. That's the taper. It's nothing super fancy or wild. But if it was two more weeks of bringing volume down, that's where I'm like, I don't like that.
Chris Striegel
I'm sure you've seen Emile Cairess' 2024 London. It's online, easy Google search. The week before the race, he did 215K of volume. So that's what, 134, 135 miles, something like that, the week before the race. And then he went on to get, what, third place at London, run 2:06. So yeah, it's crazy. So not much of a taper.
John Davis
Third place. Yeah. Even for high-mileage runners, I'm even more in favor of not doing the taper because, let's say you've been at 200K a week, so that's what, 120-something miles, for two months, three months. And okay, you're going to drop down to 80 miles, you're going to just take away this huge stimulus from your body. To the extent that training's been going well, you don't want to change anything up in terms of the stimulus to your body. You want to stay in that same rhythm so that you get to the race, you feel fresh, you're ready to go, and then you just run the race. If you're counting on, it's two weeks before the race, I feel terrible, but I'm just going to send this taper really hard, sometimes you do that and you hope for the best, but honestly, generally, that's not where I want to be.
Scotty Scearce
On the subject of taper, do you think reduction of miles or reduction of intensity of workouts is more important? So if you just kept your mileage the same or very close to it, but your intensity of workouts just plummeted, do you think that's more important than dividing the mileage?
John Davis
I think you want to maintain both to some degree. I don't want to crank any one dial very aggressively. It's funny, I almost don't even care about mileage the last two weeks before the race, because what I'm caring about is, are we getting those specific workouts in? Are we recovering after them? And then do we have at least some days in the week where you get back to whatever a normal easy day for you is volume-wise? So maybe you do a big workout. You have one super easy five-mile regeneration run, or maybe even just take the day off. And then two or three days later, are we back to whatever a normal day is for you, whether that's eight miles easy, 10 miles easy, a 12-mile, six-mile double if you're doing super high mileage? We just want to get back to that point for a couple days a week. And then I think naturally the mileage comes down a little bit, and naturally the volume of intensity comes down a little bit. That's maybe the way I would think about it. I don't think about intensity per se, I think about volume of intensity.
So I don't want to just introduce something new. I don't want to be like, okay, we're not going to do that 1K, 1K workout, we're going to do four by mile at 5K pace. Even though the volume is down, that's really new and really high intensity. So I don't want that in that last lead into the race.
Chris Striegel
Makes sense.
Volume in the specific phase, double threshold and Berardelli's lower-mileage approach
Danny Perkins
Can you talk about how you strategically apply volume to a training plan during a marathon build? Because in this plan I'm looking at now, the Hurricane 120, it looks like in the marathon-supportive phase, which is the middle phase of the block, that's when the peak mileage is hitting. And so in some ways, a lot of people think about a taper as a reduction in volume when it's also a reduction in intensity in the days leading up to the race. But this is a little bit counterintuitive to the training that I've done in the past, which is you peak in volume and intensity maybe three weeks before the race, so a little bit closer to the race. So talk about the strategic application. How are you pulling that lever of volume in training?
John Davis
Yeah, basically, obviously I want volume to be going up throughout training. I want to get to a healthy level that's sufficient to provide you with the fitness you need. You might ask, why do you need to run 120 miles a week for the marathon? Not that everybody needs to do that, but why do some people do it? A big part of it is you need to be able to do those big marathon-specific workouts. And it's a heck of a lot easier to do 20 miles at 95% of marathon pace or 16 miles at marathon pace straight through or whatever if you're able to do whatever that is, 18 miles a day of general volume. That's a really useful building block and foundation. So some of it is you only have 18 weeks in the official plan in the book. It might look a little different if you're doing a six-month huge build. In that situation, you might be up at peak volume even in the general phase.
The thing that people have a hard time wrapping their brain around is why does the volume go down somewhat in the marathon-specific phase, in the six or so weeks before the race? The reason is what you want to do in that marathon-specific phase is take the volume and intensity of the week and concentrate it into individual sessions and then really recover well. So maybe in the marathon-supportive phase, you get up to 20 miles at 90% of marathon pace. Take two-ish easy days after that, and then you're ready to go for another workout. But in the marathon-specific phase, we need that to become 95% for the same volume. Obviously, that's a harder workout. It's a bigger stress on your body, you need more recovery afterwards. So what you want is a big stress and then adequate recovery afterwards. Because, like I said earlier, if you do a really big workout like that, and you just take one easy day and then go do some hard 400s or whatever, then you are making a big mistake because you're not giving your body the recovery you need.
So in that marathon-specific phase, if you think about the week, you're concentrating the volume and intensity into really big stimuli, and then you need the recovery afterwards. And as a consequence, the volume comes down somewhat, not a lot, maybe 15% or something like that. But it's also not as big of an importance in terms of what we focus on. So if I'm coaching someone one-on-one and they're like, oh man, I really crushed that workout on the weekend, but I'm really wrecked afterwards, we just keep the volume lower for several days and then get back into it. I'm not that interested in, we better tack on a bunch of extra mileage to hit 80 or 100 or whatever it is we're looking for. I care about, did you hit that workout really well, and then did you recover well afterwards?
Chris Striegel
That makes sense. So focus more on nailing the big volume sessions, make those really big days, and then the rest of it's just, let's focus on recovering so we can do it again in this phase.
LetsRun just had Marius Bakken back on, all over their homepage and on their pod. I'm curious, on, say, the Hurricane plan, or do you think double threshold is a key element for sub-elite and elite marathoning? Do you think it's a critical type of workout to have in the build, or do you think it's not something that is required for sub-elite and elite marathoning?
John Davis
I don't think anybody can say it's critical or required, just looking at how most top marathoners and most sub-elite and elite marathoners aren't doing double threshold training. So clearly it's not mandatory.
I do think it can be a useful tool, but the use of it is a little different in the marathon. And you've probably seen I've got a chapter on this in the book, because the Hurricane plan, I believe, has at least a few double threshold sessions.
The use of double threshold in the marathon is different than for 5K or 10K, because the whole point of double threshold is to get a lot of volume in a day of this high-end aerobic work in a way that isn't stressing your body's physiological resilience mechanisms. Because if you're a 1500, 5K guy, why don't you just do 20K of threshold work in one session? Well, because your body starts falling apart, and it really destroys your ability to actually maintain that true steady state. That's great for 5K and 10K and 1500 meters. The problem is, to some extent for the half marathon, but to a very large extent for the marathon, that sort of deterioration in your body at high-end aerobic speeds is the specific demand of the race. And so you have to use double threshold as a general aspect of training, as opposed to a specific or a supportive aspect of training, if you want to use that periodization scheme that I talked about.
So let's say you do a double threshold day of four by 2K in the morning and eight by 1K in the evening, 16K of volume, and let's say across the workout it averages out to about half marathon pace. That's good general training to increase your aerobic abilities. You'll increase your threshold that way and your running economy gets better. But for the marathon, it is much better to do a specific session, such as the one you just did today, Chris, because that was also 16K of volume. And maybe the average pace is more like 97% of marathon pace or something. But hey, it's still the 8K and 8K. You did the evening session and the morning session, just you tweaked the paces a little bit and you did them continuously. That same volume of quality is more specific to the marathon, precisely because you do it in this uninterrupted way.
So you can use double threshold in marathon training two ways. The first way is in general training, to build up your general fitness with traditional-looking double threshold sessions. The second and more interesting way, which I believe is how Hurricane does it, is you can leverage the fact that double threshold isn't really stressing your body that much to get more quality in a low-stress way in the middle of two big marathon workouts. So without double threshold, let's say this weekend you do some 20-mile stepwise progression working down from 90 to 96% of marathon pace. Pretty tough workout. And then next weekend, perfect.
Chris Striegel
That's exactly what I'm doing this weekend.
John Davis
And then next weekend, maybe you're doing, I don't know, six by 3K, 1K, the 3K is at marathon pace, the 1K is at 90% of marathon pace. Also a big workout.
Here's the question. What are you going to do in the middle of the week that's not going to be so stressful on your body between those two workouts, but that still lets you build or at least maintain your fitness? Now, traditionally, in the lower volume plans in Marathon Excellence, we'll do something like eight by three minutes at a threshold-ish pace, or a five-mile fast continuous run around 105% of marathon pace, or some kind of 10K pace repeats. Not a ton of volume and not a ton of difficulty. The cleverness is you can take a slightly scaled-down double threshold session. Maybe you do three by 2K in the morning and six by 1K in the evening. Now that's 12K of volume in a much less stressful way than it would have been to do six by 2K in the morning. So that's the more advanced, sophisticated marathon-specific and marathon-supportive use of double threshold, where you're using the fact that it's low stress to sneak in more quality in a way that your body can actually survive.
But the one thing I will say, pertinent to your question, is just don't make the mistake of thinking, oh, I did a bunch of double threshold, therefore I'm ready to run the whole marathon.
Pace, mileage and volume of intensity as training metrics; cross-training vs. running volume
Chris Striegel
Yeah. The long runs are definitely the most critical part, right, in the training. You can't just do double T and then a bunch of easy long runs or whatever and expect it's going to go well.
So I think one thing that a lot of people would be curious to hear from you about is, there are so many different tools out there tracking different metrics: cadence, heart rate, lactate testing devices, right? What metrics do you like to use when you're coaching or in your own training? What are you paying most attention to? Heart rate? Are you using a lactate meter? What are you looking at?
John Davis
I'm still pretty pace-based for most of the athletes that I work with. And part of why I'm able to do that is that I have all these tools on my apps page for adjusting for wind, adjusting for hills, adjusting for heat, where I can calibrate the pace. I think it'd be different if I was working with a bunch of ultramarathoners or trail runners, where we really had to just use heart rate because there's no other good solution.
But in terms of metrics, obviously the pace of workouts is important and is the first thing I look at. I would also say I think mileage is underrated. Mileage is quite a good metric for runners, both in terms of the physiological load and the biomechanical load. Whereas in other sports, in cycling, for example, or in swimming, things get a little squirrely because just knowing how far you went doesn't tell you that much.
With running, there's this really nice correspondence where running economy is roughly constant across different speeds. And what that means is the energetic workload, the amount of oxygen you use to burn carbs or the amount of calories you burn, is basically constant. If you ran 10 miles hard or 10 miles easy, it's about the same total metabolic load on your body. And that means mileage is quite a good estimate of the total accumulated physiological load.
And the other thing I track that I think is very important is volume of intensity at specific speeds. So if we're talking about 90%, 95%, 100%, 105%, 110% of marathon pace, I'm always looking at, okay, in this workout category, let's say 105% of marathon pace, how much volume of quality did we do in that session? And are we progressing that over time? So to return to this workout you did today, right? That was 8K of volume at 105% plus 8K of volume at, say, 90%. You don't immediately want to go to 12K of volume at those speeds, because that's too big of a jump. But maybe go to 9K or 10K for the next one. Or you can say, we're going to take those 1Ks and we're going to do them as 2Ks instead. So it'll be 2K, 1K, 2K, 1K, but we're going to keep the whole volume of the session very close to 16K, so that you're controlling the physiological and the biomechanical load on your body.
Because the other issue for runners is that so much of it is an injury prevention issue in a way that it isn't for cycling or for swimming. I have friends who were swimmers in high school, or who are swimmers or swim coaches now. And you can get a 15-year-old doing two and a half hours of swimming a day, no problem, because there's no impact, no heavy biomechanical loads. Whereas in running, even an hour a day of running at 15 years old is quite a solid volume, and some people get hurt doing it.
Danny Perkins
We were talking last week on a podcast about the Norwegian cross-country skier Johannes Klæbo. And he's the guy that notoriously was ripping six-minute pace up a hill on skis in the 50K. And he just has this broad range of skill. He kills it in the shortest stuff, kills it in the 50K. He's just winning golds in every event. He broke down his training on the Ritual podcast. I don't know if you listened to that one, but he was talking about how he trains about 30, 32 hours a week. And of course, there's a few hours of running, there's more of cycling, and then most is on roller skis. Well, and cyclists train this way too, right? They're 30-something hours a week. Whereas you look at the most high-volume Kenyans, they're 140 miles, which is probably somewhere around, not quite 20, if I had to just guess.
John Davis
Yeah, it's probably 15, 16 hours a week, maybe.
Danny Perkins
15, 16.
So do you think that there's something missing? These other sports work so much volume on the aerobic development side of their training, yet runners aren't putting in that much volume because they choose to do the thing that they like doing, which is run, instead of doing cycling or cross-training. Do you think that if runners tapered it back to 10 or 12 hours of training a week, they could get maybe 10 hours of incremental cross-training on top of that? They would be way more aerobically developed and be able to run faster, because I still think you're getting that resilience, like we're talking about, that leg conditioning that's specific to our sport. And then you're getting all the aerobic development on top of that. What do you think about that kind of idea? Have you read anything or looked into that at all?
John Davis
So my intuition is no, that wouldn't work. And the reason is that if that would work, you would expect elite triathletes to be able to just come down to running and destroy everybody, right? So there are some cases like Alex Yee, right, where he came down to running training and ran quite well in the marathon. Although it's notable, that's what's really interesting.
Danny Perkins
But he trains like a runner. Yeah.
John Davis
Right? So clearly, if it was the case that the thing to do is just do 20 hours of cross-training and 10 hours of running, he would have been able to, A, run 1:58 in the marathon. And B, he would have maintained the same or very similar triathlon-looking training. And it's funny also because even in running, it is not the case that the people... and you had, recently you had Canyon on to talk about ultra training.
It's not the case that the ultrarunners who are doing unbelievable volumes can just come down and obliterate everybody at the half marathon, right? Often they can run well in the marathon or half marathon, but to the extent that they want to run a great road marathon, they have to do road marathon training. And I think this gets back to the specificity of the training thing, where
you cap out. If you're Parker Valby and you literally can't do more than some low amount of running, it is really helpful to just crank a ton of cross-training to get that general aerobic base up. But things like the elliptical, swimming, cycling, they help your general aerobic fitness, and that only goes so far. For the marathon, or for any sporting event, you need the specific demands of the race.
And my intuition is that those really big marathon-specific workouts, recovering after them is just really important, because doing the race-specific stuff is so hard on your body. You can't just go ride the bike for four hours the next three days and then still actually recover. So that's my proof case: triathletes, trail runners, it's interesting to note that they still have to switch to more running-style training when they do these specific events.
Danny Perkins
And yet those that are piling on a ton of volume, Rory going from 120 to 140 miles a week for the last Boston block and running a PR, 2:04 or whatever, these guys are still making huge gains by adding volume, right? But it's running volume. So that is interesting still. There's something there about more volume gets you more fit.
John Davis
I think to some degree and to some extent. In the book, there's a sidebar about Claudio Berardelli, who of course now is more famous for coaching Sabastian Sawe to the first sub-2 record marathon. But there was a stretch in 2009, 2010 where elite performances in the men's marathon got much better. And part of it was he was working on this approach where he was taking some of these more experienced guys in their early, mid thirties and actually bringing their volume down, but increasing the quality of the marathon-specific sessions.
So his logic was, okay, volume helps when you're younger. Cranking that volume up helps because it gives you the ability to do these big marathon-specific workouts. But if you want to keep improving, those workouts need to get bigger, they need to be longer, faster, whatever, higher quality. And when you're older, more advanced in your career, you can't do 140 miles a week and 40 kilometers at 92% of marathon pace or whatever super intensive stuff they're doing. So, okay, I'm gonna cut out some of that moderate-intensity volume. And so these guys are only gonna do 80, 90 miles a week, and they were running 2:05 on that.
And so I think mileage is a means to an end. For almost everybody, you wanna bring your volume up. But I think you can get to a point in your running career, and this applies even if we're just talking about people running 50 miles a week, where the thing you need to do to reach the higher level of those specific workouts is actually keep the easier days and the volume lower when you're doing those specific workouts. Because it's like, okay, I'm doing all this volume and I can't recover after trying to maintain ten miles a day and increase the intensity and volume of this workout. Try doing a bigger workout and then really recovering afterwards. That actually works quite well for a lot of people.
Chris Striegel
That hits pretty hard. I had a good spring last year getting up to 125 and immediately got a sacral stress fracture after the PR and then built up to 140 naturally, because I was like, 125 went really well, let's do 140. Fell flat on my face at 140. And now I've gone down to 105, 115. But I've increased the marathon sessions, the volume of workouts, and I feel good on sessions and I'm seeing progress from that. So totally agree with that point. You're hitting home with me on a lot of things.
John Davis
This gets back to how I think about periodization, where if somebody comes to me and they say, "Hey, I've got a marathon in two weeks, I just ran 16 miles at six-minute pace, and the weekend before that, I did 22 miles at 6:18 pace," I almost don't care what they did in between. They could have been doing yoga class in between. If you can do those two workouts, you're ready to run 2:37. And I think this even applies to base building when you're later in your career.
But especially for marathon-specific stuff, what you do in between in terms of volume and workouts almost just needs to be in service of only what you need to do to be able to produce the quality in the workouts. For some people, yes, that's a lot of volume. For other people, it's lowering the volume, lowering the intensity, and just being really fresh and really ready to go.
Chris Striegel
I'm curious, do you digest much running content like podcasts or YouTube? I'm curious what running content you're into, with how knowledgeable you are.
John Davis
I dig through a lot of obscure or old stuff. On my bookshelf behind me, I have this book from the legendary York High School coach Joe Newton. The book is from 1968, and it's written on a typewriter. I got it from a friend of mine who ran for York. That kind of stuff, I love that. And I also read a lot of scientific stuff too, and so that keeps me pretty busy.
Chris Striegel
Do you got The Long Green Line, the movie? Oh, classic.
John Davis
Yeah. That friend of mine, he appears for three seconds in one clip, 'cause he was a freshman that year.
Chris Striegel
My junior year, my high school team in Louisville got up to fifth in the country at one point, finished fourteenth at NXN. And Joe Newton was still coaching at York, and we went up to the Palatine Invitational in Illinois to specifically race them that season. I was our third or fourth guy coming in, it was close, and Joe Newton's on a golf cart yelling. And he was like, "That guy's saying X, catch him." Me and one of their York guys were duking it out, and I kicked him, and I was like, "Man, Joe Newton was talking about me." It's pretty sick.
And we did beat them. We did beat them at Palatine, which was cool. That was cool, 'cause I'd watched the movie a couple of times in high school. They were on hundred-mile routes.
John Davis
I try to keep up with the YouTube podcast scene, but it's not always possible. There's so much stuff coming out.
Danny Perkins
There's a lot.
John Davis
I get my nose down in some book and then I pop up and like, gosh, I missed a bunch of YouTube episodes or whatever.
Chris Striegel
There's so much new tech and fuel, new lactate gels coming out from Santa Madre and stuff. There's endless stuff to talk about. I feel like the big one people listen to for a lot of their scientific, nerding-out kind of stuff is David Roche's pod. And the Life in Stride pod, of course.
John Davis
Of course. My favorite running podcast.
Post-marathon recovery and how long a training block should be
Scotty Scearce
John, I'm curious. We've talked a lot about, very specifically, in the block, all the phases of that. What's your opinion on what to do after a block and before a block, which bleeds into after a block, depending on how quickly you race? I'm curious your opinion on that. There's a lot you can do. Rest, get right back into it, XYZ. But what do you think about that?
John Davis
If we're talking about, okay, you finished the marathon, you're back at your hotel room, what's the game plan of day one? I like to differentiate the physical recovery from the psychological recovery. You guys know this, but if you run a really hard marathon, it is just mentally, you're so spent. And your energy levels for, "I'm ready to go do some tough physical thing," even two weeks later, are pretty shot.
And I'm gonna caveat this with, I'm assuming you come off the race and nothing is hurting, you don't have any injury from the race. 'Cause that does happen sometimes. Your foot's really hurting, and so it's like, okay, we're gonna not run until that's better. I actually like to get people back doing some running, I don't know, three to five days after, depending on how they feel. It depends on how tough the race is and how they're feeling coming off.
But I'm not a big believer that you must absolutely take two complete full weeks off, no questions asked. I do tell people we're gonna take two weeks off from training, but that doesn't mean we're taking two weeks off from running. I like getting people out to just do a little bit of light, easy running, do some stuff that's gonna psychologically regenerate you. So run with your friends, run at your favorite trail or whatever. Maybe do some biking or whatever.
And then let's say now we're two weeks out, you're back doing some easy running, you feel like you're ready to start doing some actual substantive training again. This is something that's counterintuitive for people. Most people's reaction is, okay, time to ramp up the mileage, do some long runs, whatever. My reaction is no. You just did 26 miles at marathon pace. You need to start building back up all that stuff you neglected in the last six, eight, ten, twelve weeks, which actually looks a lot more like 5k pace, 3k pace, short hill repeats, the kinds of things that you can't really do in the lead-up to the marathon because they're not marathon-specific. You need to go back and start building out all of those individual foundational pieces of fitness again.
And so the first couple weeks of, call it introductory training, actually look more like 10 x 1 minute fast, 1 minute jog, or 8 x 2 minutes fast up a steep hill, or warm-up and then just 4 kilometers at 95 to 98% of 5k pace. Pretty fast, high-intensity, low-volume stuff. Hill sprints, that kind of thing. Stuff we didn't touch in the weeks leading into the marathon.
Then you get through that introductory training, and now it's like, okay, I've got two months of real fundamental training before I start my next 12-week or 18-week marathon block. That's when you take the general phase and you just run it backwards. So it's a lot of building volume, a lot of high-end aerobic stuff, Kenyan-style progression runs, and then some stuff at 5k pace, 10k pace, CV kind of situation, some long, easy runs.
The other thing I try to manage during that whole period is the pace-effort balance, or the psychological aspect of it, where far out from the marathon, or in those early few months of getting back into things, I really don't want people looking at their watch very much. Because so much of the marathon is checking those splits and really hitting them. I keep coming back to this darn 1K on/off workout, but that workout's very psychologically demanding because you're checking, okay, is the pace on? Is it off? Do I gotta speed up, slow down? And it's just too psychologically demanding to be doing that every single workout in the summer when you're doing a marathon in December, right? So that's the other piece that you want to think about in this true base-building, building-fitness phase: am I keeping the effort-pace balance appropriate?
Chris Striegel
It's funny that you keep bringing up the 1K on/off workout. I was watching Phil Sesemann's YouTube. He works out with Camille, and they did that session before, in his fall, he ran Amsterdam and Valencia. And there's that meme of someone on the couch pointing at the TV, and I was like, "That's a Canova workout."
John Davis
I recognize that.
Chris Striegel
So I thought that was funny. He's not directly coached by Canova, but it does seem like Canova is the man behind a lot of modern-day training, for sure. I would say he's probably the most important coach in modern marathoning.
John Davis
For sure.
Scotty Scearce
Before we move on from what I was just talking about, my question to you: how long do you suggest, and is this actually important? Because I have athletes that ask me this question all the time, probably top five most common question: when does the block start? When does my 16-week training plan start? When I get into the 18-to-12-week-out point, I've already started that with the people we consistently coach, but what's your opinion on that? How long is the block?
John Davis
It's much easier in the book when you're like, it's eighteen weeks and here's the plan. For people I'm coaching one-on-one, it's much more dynamic and adaptive. I have a guy who's doing New York City Marathon and Bronx 10 Mile, and he also did Utica Boilermaker. So we ride this more advanced periodization scheme.
But generally what I do is, okay, New York City Marathon, we gotta have six weeks of specific training, six weeks of supportive training. Then we'll back it up from there. How much time do we have? In this particular case, we had quite a lot of training. And so we're always on some kind of a plan, some kind of a block, usually.
But maybe what I would say in terms of limits is I don't like people going more than six months without some sort of terminal state. Maybe this is also 'cause I came up through high school and college running. I still think in terms of six-month cross country and outdoor track cycles, even for marathoners, right? I think you want to have some sort of cyclicality to your training versus, "I'm gonna do the magic week for 18 months, and then I'll be mega fit, and then I'll go run my best." I think people actually do better when they have discrete periodization cycles, even if they are longer, like six months.
So usually in practice, it's actually a function of, okay, the race ends, you do your recovery and your introductory training. And then we look ahead to what's the next thing. And then we've got specific, supportive, and we fill in general, and then does it make sense to do a half marathon block and then transition from that right into supportive marathon training, or something like that. So I don't have a "I do exactly this protocol for everybody for this amount of time." It really depends on the person and what their personal racing goals are.
Scotty Scearce
I think that's part of the whole juggling act of being a coach, coaching athletes, because people will often text me and be like, "Hey, I have a half marathon that I wanna run with my brother and it's pretty fast," and then I gotta build that into the plan. So it's a juggling act, right? There's no exact science. But if you are truly signing up for a marathon like Chicago and you're not doing anything before it, you came in decently fit, you'd be like, "Okay, we're gonna do an eighteen-week block." But in other scenarios, it's gonna be the juggling act.
John Davis
Sometimes you get a really clean example like that, right? Where it's like, okay, Chicago, it's on this day, we've got this much time. The tricky thing is, some of these races, you know over a year in advance that you're doing that race, right? So you have to, okay, I'm doing Chicago 2027, and I gotta figure out what do I do in between. And that's when you gotta go to, okay, let's do a half marathon block, then a marathon block, then this thing, and then we'll have the Chicago build. And you have that at least roughly sketched out.
Scotty Scearce
You know what's really helpful for this is Jesse Itzler's Big Ass Calendar.
John Davis
I have not seen that.
Chris Striegel
Playing it out.
Scotty Scearce
Do you know who Jesse Itzler is? Gotcha.
He sells this product. It's called a Big Ass Calendar. It's thirty dollars, might be forty. And it's basically a dry-erase board, but it's a piece of paper. He gives you two markers, a blue or a red and a black. It's this massive piece of paper, three feet by four feet probably. I put it in my closet, tape it up there. And you can see the whole year on one piece of paper. Every month is a line.
And it's extremely helpful to see your year, especially marathon blocks. There it is. I use it for marathon blocks and my employees' vacations. That's it. I found it to be helpful. Those two things stress me out. When I see them on paper, it doesn't stress me out.
John Davis
I do something similar with Google Sheets, where I have this massively tall seven-column sheet; each row is a week. And I'll have forty, fifty weeks where I can just scroll down and see, okay, this is this block, this is this block, this is this block, and here's the races. Often, five months out, I'll have a very rough sketch of, we'll do something in this space here, something in this space here.
But you gotta know, okay, Chicago's in October, and then there's these other race options. I was texting a guy yesterday about, okay, we want to do a fast marathon in Europe in the spring of 2027. Here's five options, and they're April through May. And just getting all of those on there, it's super helpful to have some version of a very long-term sketch of a plan that you can change quickly.
Chris Striegel
John, you gotta be one of the five most important guests in the running world and podcast. You have to be.
John Davis
Gosh.
Chris Striegel
Dude, the knowledge base is unbelievable.
John Davis
Well, thank you.
Chris Striegel
I'm just blown away.
Scotty Scearce
I'll second that. We're side texting, and we're gonna go all night. Usually our clock is
John Davis
Hey, my schedule's free.
Scotty Scearce
ninety minutes, we cap it, but we're definitely gonna need a round two, because we covered not nearly anything of your book. It was really just the marathon phases portion of it, which is all super interesting.
Chris Striegel
It was awesome. It's funny, there's Instagram pages with people that have a hundred thousand followers that talk about training or whatever. Dude, if you did that for two months, you would explode on socials. I think there's very few coaches in the US... There's a lot of coaching out there, right? You know your stuff, for sure.
John Davis
Thank you.
Chris Striegel
Awesome, excellent information, and one of our most valuable episodes for sure for listeners. Really awesome. Highly recommend. I'm gonna link the book in the show notes, so if people want to buy it, check it out.
John Davis
marathonexcellence.com.
Chris Striegel
Marathon Excellence site. And it's got a Canova quote in there too. So you know it means business if Canova likes it. Epic. Anything else, boys, before we wrap? We'll have John on for round two for sure and talk about other stuff that
Scotty Scearce
We definitely need a round two. Probably a round three too. Unfortunately, we don't have the Joe Rogan style where we can go five hours. Honestly, we could.
John Davis
The four-hour
Favorite races: Indy Mini, Twin Cities, Bayshore and Minnesota winters
Chris Striegel
Where are you located, John?
John Davis
Minneapolis.
Chris Striegel
Oh nice. Okay. So you're on
John Davis
I went to graduate school in... Some of you guys are in Kentucky, right?
Chris Striegel
Yes.
John Davis
I went to graduate school at IU Bloomington. One year I almost did the Kentucky Derby half, and then at the last minute I got into the Indy Mini instead and ended up doing that. But yeah, I was two hours from you.
Chris Striegel
Probably a better move to do the Indy Mini. K duck derby acts.
John Davis
It's a great race. It's a really, really competitive spring half marathon.
Scotty Scearce
You talking about the one that goes around the Indy 500 loop?
Chris Striegel
It is. No.
John Davis
Yeah, the course is: you start in downtown Indianapolis, you go to the Indy 500 Speedway, you do one loop, which is like two miles, and then you go back down, back out.
What's crazy is, because obviously they drive cars at 200 miles an hour on it, the surface is millimeter-perfect flat. And you notice the difference between that and just the regular road. You actually notice you can go significantly faster when it's perfectly flat.
Chris Striegel
Get it right away. That's fine.
What's your favorite marathon?
John Davis
Well, I live at like the three-mile mark of the Twin Cities Marathon, so I gotta say that. Grandma's Marathon's great. Let's see. Gosh, I'm really fond of all the great fall marathons in the US. Indy's great. Houston's... that's January. It's pushing it a little bit, but I would put Houston in that category.
So yeah, I feel like, other than Grandma's, we're lacking fast spring marathons right now in the US.
Chris Striegel
Dude, I agree. Bayshore Marathon is awesome in Traverse City, Michigan. We all PR there.
John Davis
Yeah, I've heard great things about Bayshore. I don't know why more people don't do it. It's a fast course and a good time of year and cool weather.
Scotty Scearce
It fills quickly. It fills in like a week. That's why more people don't do it.
Chris Striegel
Yeah, we hyped the living crap out of it, 'cause it's a great race. And I don't know, we've probably influenced some people to sign up, probably not thousands, but it is a great race.
Scotty Scearce
Couple hundred, I would say.
Chris Striegel
Yeah, you gotta sign up right away to do it. So yeah, it's a great race. I'm all about the mid-major, smaller races that are really good situations to run fast, versus hanging out at a start line for two hours before you race. That's a much better situation.
Scotty Scearce
John, I'm officially coming to Saint Paul at some point in January. My sister lives in Saint Paul, and we're running together.
John Davis
You are? Cool. All right.
Scotty Scearce
I'm gonna have the most odd group together, because we have a random amount of people that we've had on from there, I feel like. Although Dakota doesn't really live in Minnesota anymore. She doesn't train there anymore, does she?
Chris Striegel
She trains in Arizona or Florida in the winter, I think.
John Davis
Yeah, that whole group sometimes will just go down to Flagstaff for a while. 'Cause January... I tell people, come visit Minnesota May through September. That's the time to come visit. January, not the greatest training time.
Scotty Scearce
Unfortunately, I have January and February off of work, so we haven't visited my sister in like three or four years.
John Davis
Bring your winter running gear then.
Scotty Scearce
I will. I'm well aware. I've run there. The last time we were there, it was the record cold winter, so it might have been six or seven years ago then. It was the negative fifty with a negative eighty wind chill or something. Our flight got delayed for six days.
John Davis
'Cause it was too cold for the airplane to take off.
Danny Perkins
No shot.
Scotty Scearce
It was literally too cold to de-ice the plane.
Danny Perkins
They're de-icing the de-icer.
Scotty Scearce
Delta was just like, "Yeah, we're just not flying right now." It was record cold. It was a negative seventy-five degree wind chill, I remember, that one day. And it was so cold that nothing worked.
But I will be there, and I will call you, and we will run. Hopefully your hamstrings are better by then.
John Davis
Okay, sweet. We'll make it happen. I've got, what, three, four months to do it.
Chris Striegel
Get it sorted. Do smart DLs.
Scotty Scearce
Good stuff. John, thank you for your time, man.
John Davis
Yeah, thank you so much for having me on. This was a blast.
Chris Striegel
Yeah, dude. It was a fun one. Very informative. All right. Life in Stride Pod, this would be three sixty-something, I think. Catch you on the next one.
Scotty Scearce
Weren't we in the three sixties?
Chris Striegel
Maybe it's 370-something. Did we move that fast? I'll double-check.
Scotty Scearce
I don't know, bro.
Chris Striegel
No, it's 360-something. Yeah, 360-something. We're good.
Scotty Scearce
You're the boss, anyways. All right.
Chris Striegel
All right. Catch you on the next one. See ya.
Scotty Scearce
Peace.
More Top Episodes
- Episode365Dr. Bill Evans - Easy Days Too Easy + Zone 1 Thoughts, Nomio vs Beet Juice, Bicarb LotionDr. Bill Evans on race-time correlations, heat acclimatization decay, VO2 max testing, a 12-week sub-2:30 marathon plan, lactate gels and Nomio.
- Episode373Zouhair Talbi - Dreaming of Winning in NYC Marathon, Great North Run Preview, Easy Day PaceZouhair Talbi on choosing the NYC Marathon over Chicago, previewing the Great North Run, and why his easy runs start at 10:00 per mile.
- Episode375Alex Ostberg- How Charles Hicks Structures Marathon Builds, Supplements All Runners Should TakeAlex Ostberg, assistant coach to Jerry Schumacher, on Charles Hicks's 14-day marathon cycles, his Park City altitude block, and evidence-based supplements.